IT | EN | JP #MadeOfStars #Torino2019

Triple Axel landings: clean or short at Torino 2019

Torino 2019 brought the ISU Grand Prix of Figure Skating Final to the Palavela arena in Turin from 5 to 8 December. Senior and Junior events across men’s, ladies’, pairs and ice dance made the programme a complete guide to competitive figure skating. The most instructive moments were often the jumps: a fraction of a rotation, a rushed exit or a perfectly controlled landing separated useful results from confusing ones.

A triple Axel is one continuous action, not simply an airborne spin. The skater takes off from a forward inside edge, completes three and a half counterclockwise rotations and lands backward on the same foot. A clean landing lets the toe pick meet the ice only after that rotation is finished, with the body centred and the free leg clear.

Learning how to spot a clean landing on a triple Axel versus a short landing gives spectators a more reliable way to interpret both the performance and the technical panel’s decision. Height, speed and the noise of the arena can distract from the real checks: rotation, toe-pick contact, body alignment and control after touchdown.

For Australian viewers, December also meant summer rather than Turin’s winter. Live sessions fell across Australian mornings, evenings or overnight, depending on the starting time. The skating culture of Melbourne, Sydney and Brisbane supplies plenty of informed audiences, but even experienced club skaters often use slow-motion replays to settle a close rotation call.

Clean and short landings, side by side

The quickest comparison is to separate rotation from landing quality. A skater may rotate fully and still land awkwardly, or land neatly after coming around too early. Both problems matter, yet they produce different deductions.

Visual cue Clean triple Axel Short or underrotated landing
Rotation All three and a half rotations finish before toe-pick contact Rotation stops early and the toe pick arrives first
Toe pick and blade Toe pick points cleanly in the direction of travel Blade angles across the ice or lands awkwardly
Body axis Hips and shoulders remain stacked over the supporting foot Torso twists, drifts sideways or continues turning after touchdown
Touchdown One controlled contact followed by knee flexion Brush, chop, second-foot contact or a stumble
Free leg and exit Free leg stays clear and the skater holds the edge or exits with speed Free leg comes down, an urgent step follows or control is visibly lost

At normal broadcast speed, a short landing can look convincing because the skater often keeps moving and covers the error with a polished arm position. A side-on replay exposes the sequence: the toe pick arrives before the final half-turn, the hips unwind early, or the upper body keeps twisting after the blade is already down. Crowd noise is a poor guide; a firm ice contact can conceal a poorly centred landing.

Judges also separate what happened from how it happened. Rotation determines whether the intended jump was completed, while execution grades consider control, edge use and the quality of the landing. That is why a smooth-looking exit can accompany an underrotated jump, while a low but balanced landing may still be clean.

What makes the triple Axel complete

The entry sets up everything. On a triple Axel, the skater travels forward, places the toe pick of the landing foot on the ice and rises from the inside edge. The arms draw in, the free leg folds or changes position for balance, and the shoulders begin the rotation without tipping the axis sideways.

During flight, follow the axis from head to hips and hips to supporting foot. A well-centred triple Axel may look compact because all the parts rotate together. The free leg can open to control speed, but it should not drag the rotation off line. Elevation helps clearance, yet it is not the jump’s main measure; a high attempt that arrives underrotated is still an underrotated jump.

At touchdown, the toe pick should point cleanly in the direction of travel and make one decisive contact. The knee flexes to absorb the landing, the torso stays over the blade, and the free leg remains lifted or moves purposefully into the next position. The skater should be able to hold the edge for a beat or exit with speed. A controlled, low absorption is not a flaw.

How a short landing gives itself away

“Short landing” is useful spectator shorthand, but it is not one formal ISU category. It usually means that some part of the jump was cut short, especially the rotation. Underrotation occurs when the skater comes around before three and a half turns are complete and places the toe pick down early. A rough landing with full rotation is different: the jump may count, but execution deductions can reflect the instability.

The visual signs often arrive in a sequence. The toe pick touches before the torso has finished turning; the hips stop while the shoulders continue; or the blade lands across the direction of travel. The skater may then step out, check the arms or rush into the next movement to recover the lost rotation. Any brush of the free foot or second-foot contact is an added execution problem, not proof of underrotation by itself.

Older skating footage includes a tactic called checkerboarding, in which a toe plant was combined with a step around the planted foot to disguise missing rotation. Modern judging considers the complete jump and compares the entry, rotation and landing, making that kind of correction harder to hide. Depending on the amount of rotation missing, the technical panel may reduce the execution grade or decline to award the intended jump value. A fall is a separate outcome, not merely a short landing.

What cameras and replays can reveal

Camera angle can determine what a spectator notices. The Palavela’s wide live view shows speed, balance and the relationship between the skater and the ice, but a replay from the side is better for the toe pick. Freeze the frame where the free leg passes the body and compare the shoulder line with the blade. A clean jump keeps the axis stacked; a short attempt often shows the hips arriving before the shoulders.

Use the same athlete as a control. If several single jumps finish cleanly while one triple Axel is short, the problem may lie in the takeoff, rotation speed or confidence at that particular moment. If the landing foot is consistently late, unstable or poorly placed, an edge or landing-position issue may be more likely. The official result then matters: it records the value awarded and any deductions, while the video reveals why.

For Australian viewers, timing needs a state-by-state check. In December, Turin is on Central European Time, UTC+1. Sydney and Melbourne are on AEDT, UTC+11, so they are ten hours ahead; Brisbane is nine hours ahead; Adelaide and Darwin are eight and a half hours ahead; and Perth is seven hours ahead. The same Turin session can therefore appear on different calendar dates across Australia. Broadcast rights and streaming catalogues vary by market, making official replays and locally scheduled sports coverage useful for fans watching at home or meeting at a sports bar.

A practical checklist for sharper viewing

A reliable viewing routine uses the same order every time. Watch once at normal speed for the overall impression, then change the angle and slow the sequence before making a judgement. Keep the landing and the official call separate until the evidence has been reviewed.

The same discipline works beyond the Palavela. At a club competition in Melbourne or a national stream watched in Brisbane, commentators often have less time and fewer camera angles, so the distinction becomes even more valuable.

Make the next review active: open the official Torino 2019 results and highlights, save one clean triple Axel and one short or underrotated attempt, and compare them frame by frame. Use the event schedules, competitor profiles and venue information on the official site to identify the discipline and athlete, then share the comparison with a skating club or training group. That simple exercise turns a familiar jump into a measurable skill and makes every later broadcast easier to read.